The Ongoing Debate: Are Dreams Meaningful or Random?
There is an ongoing debate about whether dreams are a vehicle for messages or merely random by-products of the brain. Both sides of the argument are briefly summarized here.
The Ongoing Debate
Though mystics have long seen dreams as messages from the soul, psychologists remain divided. Some researchers conclude that dreams carry meaning, while others theorize that dreams are random images without intentional significance. As is the nature of scientific inquiry, this debate is ongoing.
Dreams as Meaningless, Random Events
Those who view dreams as meaningless believe that dream imagery is related to the random, spontaneous firing of brain cells (neurons), which fire like blinking lights turning on and off. This process is thought to be part of the brain's housekeeping and upkeep. Proponents such as Francis Crick and Graeme Mitchson suggest that cells in the hindbrain (lower brain stem) spontaneously activate cells in higher brain centers (the cortex), producing the nightly imagery we call dreams. In this view, dreams are random events created by individual brain cells firing at random during the night.
Dreams as Meaningful
Those who believe that dreams are meaningful agree that brain cells engage in spontaneous firing but consider that fact irrelevant. They theorize that, like a computer, the brain has built-in neuronal mechanisms that enable it to process thoughts, feelings, and experiences. One such mechanism relates to dreaming.
These psychologists point to other brain processes, such as language learning in children. Linguist Noam Chomsky describes language patterns as "deep" versus "surface" structures, suggesting that children absorb complex language patterns without coaching, which indicates that the brain has a built-in template for language learning. Similarly, theorists suggest that the brain has templates associated with dreaming.
Scientific Support for Meaningful Dreams
Researchers Aaron Greenberg and Milton Kramer support the idea that dreams are meaningful, pointing to studies suggesting that dreaming helps maintain emotional and psychological balance. Their research on traumatized war veterans and those with emotional disorders indicates that dreams play a key role in emotional recovery. They found that dream storylines often relate to real-life events and needs, leading them to conclude that dreams do indeed carry meaning.
Do Dreams Carry Messages?
Apart from scientific debates, many individuals claim to receive specific insights and messages in their dreams. Dream enthusiasts will continue to analyze their dreams for personal meaning, regardless of ongoing scientific speculation or conclusions.
See Also: Dreams, Meaningful Dreams, R, om Dreams, Neurons, Emotional Balance
[1]